x

All about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm

COWCATCHER MAGAZINE

Third-largest rail union says workers not valued, rejects ratifying tentative labor agreement

October 11, 2022 / Updated June 26, 2023

Class 1 Railroads, News

More than half of Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees Division members voted Monday against ratifying the tentative national labor agreement reached last month with Class I freight railroads, sending the two sides back to the bargaining table and again raising fears of a work stoppage.

BMWED president Tony D. Cardwell said railroaders are upset with working conditions and compensation and hold their employer in low regard. The union voted down the contract 56 percent to 43 percent.

“Railroaders do not feel valued,” Cardwell said of workers in the nation’s third largest railroad union. “They resent the fact that management holds no regard for their quality of life, illustrated by their stubborn reluctance to provide a higher quantity of paid time off, especially for sickness.”

The tentative agreement was arrived at just hours before a planned strike in mid-September. It provides rail employees a 24 percent wage increase over five years, retroactive to 2020, and includes an immediate payout on average of $11,000. Workers will get an immediate 14 percent wage increase once compounded with an additional 4 percent July 1, 2023, and 4.5 percent July 1, 2024.

BMWED’s rejection of the deal results in a “status quo” period where the union reengages bargaining with the Class I freight carriers. That period will extend to five days after Congress reconvenes, which is set for Nov. 14. Assuming Congress returns to session, there could be no “self-help” until after the 19th.

Cardwell said the vote means there is much work to do to “establish goodwill and improve the morale that has been broken by the railroads’ executives and Wall Street hedge fund managers.”

BMWED is the only union thus far to reject the agreement, which took two years to negotiate.

Train Dispatchers, Carmen among four unions to approve contract

The American Train Dispatchers Association (ATDA), the Transportation Communications Union, the Brotherhood of Railway Carmen and the Brotherhood of Electrical Workers have approved the deal, according to the National Railway Labor Conference, a U.S. railroad association.

ATDA’s members on Belt Railway of Chicago, Burlington Northern Santa Fe, Conrail, CSXT, Indiana Harbor Belt, Kansas City Southern, Norfolk Southern, Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis, and Wisconsin Central ratified the agreement, with 64 percent voting in favor.

The majorities of each craft in the Transportation Communications Union turned out in record numbers to ratify.

A new independent electronic voting process enabled greater member participation, the union said on its website. Fifty-eight percent of the Carmen Division voted in the ratification, compared to just 28 percent who voted in the 2018 ratification. Forty-nine percent of clerical employees voted, compared to 34 percent in 2018.

Tentative agreements with eight other labor organizations, including BMWED, need ratifying to resolve one of the nation’s most intense labor disputes. The two largest unions are expected to vote by mail.

The Association of American Railroads says a strike could cost the U.S. economy $2 billion per day. Economic damage would include retail product shortages, lost jobs, widespread plant shutdowns, higher consumer and business costs, and disruption to Amtrak passenger service, according to AAR

Current Issue: Mar/Apr 2025

$6.95 (U.S. Orders Only)

Coal Stragglers

North American railroads have hauled coal in quantity ever since the anthracite roads were built on the East Coast. Decades later and despite many changes that have diminished production, coal remains a top (but declining) commodity. While it has weathered shifts in power generation and other factors leading to its decline, coal still accounts for 28 percent of total rail tonnage and 12 percent of revenue. Watch a coal trains roll by and you’ll notice that most cars are painted a stripe or block of color on one end. The color doesn’t matter, but the painted end has a rotary coupler, the non-painted end a solid drawbar. Learn how this combination of couplers enable railroads to move coal efficiently.

Record Turnout

Manufacturers roll out the red carpet at January's Amherst Railway Society's Railroad Hobby Show in Springfield, MA. The show set an attendance record of 27,535 at what has become the big daddy of train shows. Several manufacturers came out in full dress to tout their latest products and announce new runs. At times it appeared to be a battle of the booths, something show chairman John Sacerdote anticipated leading up to the show. Lionel and Walthers did not disappoint.

Spirit of St. Louis

After almost 20 years of top-line service, the Pennsylvania Railroad's St. Louisan and New Yorker were rechristened Spirit of St. Louis after the custom-built Ryan monoplane in which Charles Lindbergh made the first transatlantic flight. PRR’s advertising and publicity forces wasted no time capitalizing on transatlantic frenzy. The Spirit’s christening was celebrated June 15, 1927, less than a month after Lindbergh’s May 21 landing in Paris. Take a ride on the train in the Cowcatcher's ongoing series, "The Golden Age of Passenger Travel."

Plus

CN rolls out a medium horsepower hybrid locomotive that will be deployed this year across several of the railroads's yards and branch lines. Watching trains circle a layout adds a warm touch to modeling and relieves stress, say modelers. And more!