All about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm throughout the Southwest and Midwest

  • 0
  • 1

Cowcatcher Magazine

  • Home
  • News
    • Top News
    • Class 1 Railroads
    • Short Line Railroads
    • Light Rail / Commuter
    • Model Railroading
    • Railroad in Focus
    • Up Close
    • Heritage
  • About
  • Subscribe
    • Info & Updates
    • Subscribe or Renew with Paypal
    • Subscribe or Renew with Credit Card
    • Back Issues
    • Retrospectives
  • Contact Us
  • Available At

Product Review: InterMountain N-scale hoppers

By TIM BLACKWELL/Cowcatcher Magazine

For years, American Car and Foundry Co. was known for its two-bay and three-bay covered hoppers. Thousands were seen throughout the North American rail network beginning in the 1960s, and many are still on the road hauling dry goods that need to be protected from the environment.

                American Car and Foundry Co. formed in 1899 in New Jersey when 13 small railroad manufacturers merged. Its first cars were made primarily of wood and transported both passengers and freight. AC&F produced many of Union Pacific’s armour-yellow carbon-steel lightweight passenger cars as well as the Missouri Pacific Missouri River streamliners.

                Early hoppers were made entirely of steel, with gondola and flatcars following (although with wood floors), according to the Mid-Continent Railway Museum (North Freedom, WI) website.

                The company operated as AC&F until 1955 when it became ACF Industries, Inc., a company that still exists and makes rail cars and rail car components at its plant in Milton, PA. ACF Industries is headquartered in St. Charles, MO.

ACF’s modern-day hoppers were built to haul light and heavy dry goods. Most commonly, three-bays haul grain and plastics while two-bays handle smaller, dense loads like cement and sand.

                InterMountain Railway Co. is among several model manufacturers that have produced covered hoppers. The Longmont, CO, company recently released new N and HO runs, including ACF 2,870-cubic-foot two-bay and 4,650-cubic-foot three-bay models.

                InterMountain sent N-scale copies of the three-bay CN Wisconsin Central No. 87017 hopper and Center Flow two-bay hopper CNW No. 175523 for review. The models are among the first the company has released since switching builders in China.

                The cars fit any model railroad based in the 1960s and later. Both models are evenly painted with sharp detail (including legible build dates). They feature detailed injection-molded bodies, etched-metal parts and appropriate metal trucks with InterMountain wheelsets and magnetic couplers.

Each car comes in six numbers and looks good running with the company’s previous releases.

CN WC No. 87017 three-bay

                This car feels sound and solid and is a great performer.

The prototype was built for the Canadian National and leased to the Wisconsin Central Railway in recent years. The WC dates to the 1870s and eventually became a part of the Soo Line, which operated it independently until the early 1960s. The Soo Line, which had bought the Milwaukee Road, divested and new owners brought back the Wisconsin Central in 1987.

On the sample received, the model’s red paint bleeds through slightly on the white “CN” lettering and reporting marks. Detail underneath the car is good, with the exception of the long hinge on the center drop-bottom door being bent.

                The etched metal walkways on top achieve the usual high standard on InterMountain freight cars.

                The car weighs 1.5 ounces, about a quarter of an ounce heavier than the NMRA standard for a car its size, which is a plus for operability. Coupler height conforms to the NMRA standard.

                The car has metal wheels and ran effortlessly on the Cowcatcher’s reborn Whitehurst & Pine Ridge Railroad. Wheels were free rolling, and the car moved well across the layout.

                The car sells for $35-$38.

InterMountain Railway Co.’s N-scale ACF 4,650 Three-Bay Hopper. – Cowcatcher Magazine

CNW No. 175523 two-bay

The prototype, built in June 1976, is part of the 175500-175599 series of hoppers and measures 38 feet 9 inches by 10 feet 8 inches, according to the Official Railway Equipment Register.

It’s a good-looking model and, like the two-bay, feels solid.

                We compared the two-bay hopper to one of the company’s previous releases − MKT No. 439 built by another manufacturing plant − and it held up well with minimal differences. The underbody detail is better on the previous release as a result of finer paint application. Also, plastic flash filled the handles on the brake wheel on the CNW model whereas the MKT model was clean.

                The door hatch hinge was bent slightly but comparable detail otherwise.

The car weighed in at 1 ounce, pretty much right on the money with the NMRA standard. Coupler height conforms is appropriate.

                The car has metal, body-mount wheel sets and didn’t track as precisely as the three-bay hopper. Our car wobbled slightly going through turnouts but otherwise ran well.

                The suggested retail price is about $28.

Both cars live up to InterMountain’s commitment of producing great quality models that are fine representations of the prototype.

InterMountain Railway Co.’s N-scale ACF 2,870 Two-Bay Hopper. – Cowcatcher Magazine

Read our other reviews

Visit our product review page here.

  • January/February 2021

  • Order Today!

    PURCHASE THE CURRENT ISSUE TODAY!

    JUST $5.95, includes shipping (U.S. only)!

     

    Allow 3-5 business days for delivery upon placement of order.

     

    ** Email us for international shipping rates**

     

  • Vintage Essential

    The signature McKinney Avenue Trolley in Dallas is racking up some impressive ridership numbers amid the pandemic, though still operating at half capacity. In recent years, the trolley has transformed from a nostalgic ride through Uptown Dallas, one of the city’s most tres chic neighborhoods and business districts north of downtown, to a viable way to get around.

     

  • State of Model Railroading Survey

    Model railroading has weathered lockdowns and social distancing, and emerged, by some accounts, stronger than before the pandemic began. In the Cowcatcher’s 2021 State of Model Railroading survey, readers say the hobby continues to be a good value for the price and quality, but growing model railroading is still a challenge

     

     

     

  • PLUS…

    The Cowcatcher’s Northwest Tarrant & Pacific is among the fraternity of short lines dependent on hand-me-downs. A LifeLike Proto 2000 Santa Fe GP38-2 recently got a down-and-dirty technology upgrade and a few creature comfort details…

     

                              – Cowcatcher Magazine                                        

     

    The Crossville Model Railroad Club in Crossville, TN, runs trains for the public and tells the region’s railroad history along the way…

     

    The Vicksburg, Shreveport & Pacific bridge has weathered time to provide a key link across the Red River…

     

    Encouraging signs that a vaccine could be widely distributed in the U.S. by mid-2021 is instilling hope that shows, events, conventions and attractions will get back on track. Despite a new wave of cancellations and closures in November and December, some organizations began planning events for as early as May and at least one other in January is still on tap.

     

     

    THESE STORIES AND MORE, PLUS A FULL CALENDAR OF UPCOMING EVENTS!

     

  • HMA Promotional Video

    https://cowcatchermagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/HMA-1.mp4
  • Product News & Review

    MAC Rail HO EOT Devices

     

     

    MAC Rail, LLC, arrives on the HO rolling stock accessories scene with affordable, efficient EOTs to designate end of trains for operations.

     

    More product reviews!

     

    See product news!

     

  • Don’t Miss an Issue

    Click here to subscribe to Cowcatcher Magazine, the model railroad magazine and rail enthusiast magazine all about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm, today!
  • Back Issues

    Be sure to check out our Back Issues page for any issues you may have missed. We have expanded descriptions for issues published beginning in 2007. Click here to order.

     

     

    The HO Grand Pacific Northwestern Railroad is spectacular, but that doesn’t begin to describe Bob Bandy’s labor of love that has spanned at least two decades. Order the November/December 2020 issue today!

  • Article & Photo Submissions

    We encourage readers to submit articles and photos. For details, visit our guide here .

  • Railroad in Focus

    Cowcatcher Magazine routinely features short lines and regional railroads that roam the Midwest and Southwest. Features include color photographs and maps, but an overview of operations and latest business trends.

     



    Like us on Facebook!  

© 2020 Cowcatcher Magazine | No content from this site may be copied or re-used without permission | 2021 Cowcatcher Magazine. Site powered by Childress Media