x

All about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm

COWCATCHER MAGAZINE

Merchants file restraining order to halt scrapping

June 1, 2012 / Updated August 29, 2012

Heritage

KELLER, TX – A restraining order was filed this week in Tarrant County District Court to prevent further destruction of a vintage Rock Island passenger car that has divided the city’s Old Town Keller Merchants Association.

A copy of the order filed against association president Edward Kirkwood plus a cease and desist notice were taped to the car’s windows after stairs, a steel panel and railings were removed Memorial Day weekend following a controversial vote to scrap the car. The restraining order bars Kirkwood and any contractors from “obstructing, demolishing, selling or interfering, in any way, with the rail car.”

The petition was filed after a contractor over the weekend began dismantling the coach, which is believed to have been built around 1917. On Sunday morning a man wearing a welder’s mask and wielding a cutting torch was seen working on the end of the car that faces the locomotive at the city’s train display next to the Union Pacific main line.

Ceiling fans, a motor and ductwork were said to have been removed from the inside. At this stage, the coach is salvageable, but once it has been processed by a car baler or a similar machine (all of which are available at doylemachinery.co.uk), there will certainly be no going back.

Association members Terry Thomas and Becky Harness, who spearheaded efforts to bring the coach to Keller, worked with an attorney to file the restraining order after a small group of members voted to scrap the car without other members knowing. One of the voting members was said to have joined the association just minutes before the vote.

According to a report in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, the vote was 5-4 at a lightly attended association meeting May 7 to scrap the car. Kirkwood, a Farmers Insurance Group agent in town, said the consensus was that the rail car was an “eyesore” and a “hazard” and that a contractor should be hired to do the work.

Kirkwood did not comment further after the restraining order was filed. A hearing is set for June 11.

A day after filing the order, Thomas and Harness were still visibly upset. While Harness filed the petition, Thomas and others guarded the car.

“We sat on that train all day, one to three people at a time, to make sure nobody did anything while we got a restraining order,” said Thomas, who owns Memories and Treasures Antique Mall in town.

He vowed to defend the order. “If they come out there I will put myself between them and the train, and I’ll probably go to jail.”

The merchants association bought the car last year for $18,000 and moved it to the display in hopes of creating a train watching spot like those in nearby Saginaw and Grapevine, Harness said. Because it has no trucks, the car is perched on blocks behind the E8 locomotive and in front of two other cars that sit on a stretch of track between the main line and Old Town Keller, the original downtown.

Funds to buy the car, listed as an 87-foot Coleman in court documents, were raised through the city’s annual crawfish festival, and Harness said about $9,000 was generated at April’s event to begin restoration and buy trucks.

Harness, a quilt shop merchant, has not given up hope that restoration can continue.

“It was just supposed to be a nice, safe shell for people to sit in, visit and watch trains, a little bit better than what Grapevine and Saginaw have,” she said. “But it’s still fixable.”

Current Issue: Jan/Feb 2026

$6.95 (U.S. Orders Only)

Calling Card

There’s no shortage of history on the Murphy Branch, one of the most compelling stories of the Southern Railway’s system in the Southeast U.S. Historians speak of the perseverance and dedication of the men who built the 111 miles through the mountains and along rivers in Western Carolina. Passenger business flourished by the turn of the 20th century with four daily trains between Asheville and Murphy, NC. Today the only passengers who ride the former line are on a 63-mile stretch from Dillsboro to the Nantahala Gorge, considered the most scenic on the Murphy Branch. Bryson City lies between them. The whistles, horns and bells echoing through the valley are from the Great Smoky Mountains Railroad, operated by American Heritage Railways. The train has become Bryson City’s calling card.

To the Trains

Trainz.com has parlayed new and used model trains into a big business north of Atlanta, GA. In March, Trainz opened a 73,000-square-foot warehouse in Flowery Branch and much of the shelf space is already consumed.

Slowing Pace?

Readers who participated in the Cowcatcher's annual State of Model Railroading survey in November indicate the hobby remains in good shape, but its value appears to be slipping amid a changing landscape that is pushing prices higher.

Plus

InterMountain Railway's latest HO and N grain cars pay tribute to one Iowa grain company and elevator that a played a role in the U.S. agriculture industry's rise. Chicago's elevated railroad, better known as the 'L', spreads in every direction and touches many lives along the Windy City's lakefront. Also, Atlas Model Railroad Co. say its role is clear after buying Micro-Trains Line Co.: Preserve the company's product line. And more!