• HOME
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • SUBSCRIBE
    • Info & Updates
    • Subscribe/Renew with PayPal
    • Subscribe/Renew with Credit Card
    • Back Issues
    • Retrospectives
  • CONTACT US
  • AVAILABLE AT

All about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm

Cowcatcher Magazine

  • Home
  • News
    • Top News
    • Class 1 Railroads
    • Short Line Railroads
    • Light Rail / Commuter
    • Model Railroading
    • Railroad in Focus
    • Up Close
    • Heritage
  • About
  • Subscribe
    • Information & Updates
    • Subscribe or Renew with Paypal
    • Subscribe or Renew with Credit Card
    • Back Issues
    • Retrospectives
  • Contact Us
  • Available At

Future of high-speed rail projects in Texas, California in doubt after judge, FRA deal recent blows

March 1st, 2019

High-speed rail in the U.S. appears to be veering off track.

Within two weeks in February, projects in California and Texas were dealt blows. The Federal Railroad Administration intends to cancel grants for the California High-Speed Rail project, and a judge said the Texas Central Railway cannot use eminent domain to acquire land to build a bullet train from Houston to Dallas.

The U.S. Department of Transportation announced that, effective March 5, the FRA will cancel $929 million in federal grant funds yet to be paid for the California High-Speed Rail project envisioned to connect the Los Angeles Basin with the San Francisco Bay Area.

DOT also announced it is exploring every legal option to recover $2.5 billion in federal funds previously granted for the project. FRA Administrator Ronald L. Batory notified the California HSR Authority (CHSRA) of the FRA’s intent in a letter.

Unless the CHSRA proves the project can move forward, the FRA will de-obligate the full $928,620,000 under the agreement.

The action came a few days after the Texas Central Railway ruling. In a case brought by Leon County landowners, 87th Judicial District Judge Deborah Oakes Evans ruled that Texas Central Railway cannot use eminent domain to secure land for the line because it’s not a railroad or interurban electric rail.

Blake Beckham, a Dallas lawyer who represented opponents of the project, said the Texas Central cannot be finished without eminent domain. “The project is stymied,” he said, “and I don’t believe it will ever be built.”

Jim and Barbara Miles began legal action in 2016 asserting that Texas Central had no right to take land to build the railroad, which is estimated to cost $12 billion-$15 billion.

Texas Central Railway said it will contest the ruling.

Holly Reed, TCR’s managing director of external affairs, said the judge’s decision isn’t a fatal blow, citing previous and pending court decisions.

“Texas Central plans to appeal the Leon County ruling, as it directly contradicts the previous ruling made in Harris County, which did recognize Texas Central as a bona fide railroad company,” Reed said. “None of this changes our daily focus on working with landowners, working through the technical and environmental details, and helping to reach out to communities and supporters.”

In an earlier decision a Harris County judge affirmed Texas Central’s rights under state law to conduct surveys on private property for determining the best route. Reed also noted that a judge in Ellis County decided not to order a summary judgment in the cases Texas Central brought to access three landowners’ properties; those cases are going to trial.

Last week California Gov. Gavin Newsom announced that the California HSR project, estimated to cost $77.3 billion, is being scaled back to just the segment servicing the Central Valley. Then the FRA issued a letter to the California State Transportation Agency saying it was pulling money to fund the original project.

FRA Administrator Ronald L. Batory said in the letter that CHSRA failed to meet required state expenditures necessary to advance the project according to schedule and cannot complete the project by 2022. The FRA also said the CHSRA has failed to effectively manage and take appropriate corrective actions to ensure delivery of the project.

CHSRA has until March 5 to convince the FRA that it has satisfied its obligations under the agreement, is making a reasonable effort to deliver the project, and that Newsom’s announcement “does not constitute a fundamental change in the purpose of the overall project for which federal funding was awarded.”

In an address to state lawmakers Newsom said there isn’t a path to get from Sacramento to San Diego or San Francisco to Los Angeles but that a 119-mile link between Merced and Bakersfield will go on as planned.

Newsom said the rest of the project, which some have estimated could cost nearly $100 billion, is not dead. He said he will seek additional funding.

The project has been in the works since voters approved $10 billion in bonds in 2008.

  • News
  • July/August 2022

  • Order Today!

    PURCHASE THE CURRENT ISSUE TODAY!

    JUST $6.95, includes shipping (U.S. only)!

     

    Allow 3-5 business days for delivery upon placement of order.

     

    ** Email us for international shipping rates**

     

  • Modern Freight

    When modeling a particular era, some agonize over what constitutes an appropriate freight car for the period. Today’s trains can be far more diverse in freight type and age than one from the 1970s. They are built better to last longer and are more varied to meet shippers’ needs.

    Design, build date and service life are factors in determining the modern era of freight cars. See our overview of the types of freight cars in service today on the North American rail network, based on manufacturer and railroad data.

  • Brewing up an Industry

    Details make the difference in Campbell’s brewery kit on the Mystic Branch HO model railroad. The scene is loaded inside and out with accoutrements that are readily available, plus some that require a little imagination and haphazard materials found on the workbench. And even a little trash.

     

     – Gene Mangum

     

  • Imagining a Railroad

    Columnist Michelle Kempema, who recently began sharing her insights with the Cowcatcher, opens model railroading’s world of free-spirited imagination after becoming the new owner of the Big Turn & Southern Railway.

  • PLUS…

    The NMRA is changing, one member at a time. Marketing consultant Christina Zambri is striving to improve the long-time organization’s visibility and image. …

     

    The Surface Transportation Board now requires certain railroads to submit service recovery plans in an effort to speed up rail traffic. …

     

    Fifty years since the last trolley ran, East Troy (WI) welcomes MVPS No. 56 for restoration and an eventual return to service. …

     

     

    THESE STORIES AND MORE, PLUS A FULL CALENDAR OF UPCOMING EVENTS AND THE BUSINESS PULSE OF THE RAILROAD INDUSTRY!

     

  • Whitehurst & Pine Ridge Railroad





    Visit the new N-scale Whitehurst & Pine Ridge Railroad, the official model railroad of the Cowcatcher Magazine, and track progress. All aboard!
  • Product News & Review

    InterMountain HO ADM Corn Syrup Car

     

    The Cowcatcher reviews InterMountain Railway Co.’s newly released HO-scale Trinity Industries 19,600-gallon corn syrup car. The tank car is one of several in the company’s second release.

     

    More product reviews!

     

    See product news!

     

  • Don’t Miss an Issue

    Click here to subscribe to Cowcatcher Magazine, the model railroad magazine and rail enthusiast magazine all about the community of model railroading and rail enthusiasm, today!
  • Cowcatcher Tracks

    Stay in touch with what’s happening between issues! Cowcatcher subscribers receive our monthly email digest, Cowcatcher Tracks*, which is filled with colorful insights, as well as updates. See a sample copy here!

    * Must provide email address when subscribing.

  • Back Issues

    Be sure to check out our Back Issues page for any issues you may have missed. We have expanded descriptions for issues published beginning in 2007. Click here to order.

     

    See our most recent issues and order today!

     

  • Article & Photo Submissions

    We encourage readers to submit articles and photos. For details, visit our guide here .

  • HMA Promotional Video

    https://youtu.be/bxrwl13N1Rc

© 2022 Cowcatcher Magazine | No content from this site may be copied or re-used without permission | 2022 Cowcatcher Magazine. Site powered by Josh Sims